'Mexico! Mexico!'


So let them go back to "Mexico! Mexico!"

It's not that I lack compassion for these poor people who flood across our border in search of a better life. But defying our laws to do so just isn't cool. Neither is it all that compatible with our national security.

It's perfectly true that we are a nation of immigrants. It's also true that these folks take jobs nobody else would want. But if they want to be a part of our society, they need to become a part of our society- and playing by the rules is a good start.

So is learning the language- not necessarily immediately, mind you. Adjusting to a new culture takes time, and plenty of immigrants in the past have had a generation go by before English became the language of the home- and were no less good Americans for all that.

But on the other hand, during my time in the Washington, D.C. area, I learned what it's like not to be able to go into a McDonald's in one's own country and order a carton of skim milk without talking to the manager so that she can translate. Basic job skills include an ability to communicate on a level sufficient to perform the duties of one's job- or to live as a member of a larger community with a common life.

And it involves sharing in that common life. That means replacing "Mexico! Mexico!" with "America! America!"

HT: Drudge

Comments

Anonymous said…
I just can't get on board with the "jobs that Americans won't take" concept. When has any unnecessary work been left undone in America? Who dug up the potatoes in Maine before illegal aliens? National security concerns notwithstanding, open borders might work if their weren't so many free entitlements. Government (taxpayer) supported schools and hospitals cannot continue to be solvent when they are overrun by non-tax contributing people. Forced compassion is an oxymoron.
This is the first time in our history that Americans' education and expectations are so high precisely the situation you describe exists. Would you be happy working at McDonalds', or as a janitor? Few Americans would be.

There was a time when a college education was something for the elite. For decades now, it's been what a high school education once was. And who does the jobs that don't even require a high school education?

The "forced compassion" part is true. So is the economic argument. But there is a place in our economy for these folks- in controlled numbers, entering the job market as they can be accomodated.

And by rules we set.

Popular Posts